Русская версия

( Translate with Google )

Main page > Conferences > The European Gas Market: Diversification False Start?

The European Gas Market: Diversification False Start?

Konstantin Simonov’s speech presentation at The United Nations Economic Commission for Europe Gas Work Group Session.

Moscow, March 30, 2010.

1.The European Gas Market : D iversification F alse S tart? Konstantin Simonov National Energy Security Fund Moscow March 30, 2010 2.Has 2009 been the year of the great gas revolution ? P ro argument s : The Shale Revolution in the US market Growth of liquefied gas supplies to Europe D iminution in the demand for gas in Europe Energy saving development Renewable energy industry Construction of interconnector gas pipelines 3.Ideal scheme for Europe 1. The USA reject s imports of gas . 2. They don’t need LNG in North America , and it rushes to the EC. 3. Europe implements ‘ 20-20-20 strategy’ and improves its energy efficiency . 4. Europe builds interconnectors , liberalizes gas transportation infrastructure , dramatically increases the number of LNG receiving terminals . 5. Gas surplus occurs in the EC market; the EC give s up the Groningen System and comes down to spot trading . Gas prices slump. 6. Shale gas production begins in the EC which finally buries Russia and other major conventional gas suppliers. 4.However, it's not all as easy as it sounds Reduction of gas consumption would be hard to achieve – it will require a complete technological revolution. E nergy efficiency may fail as a stake on alternative energy sources – as it has already happened with the biofuel, with which they've already tried to frighten the hydrocarbon producers some years ago. The crisis is not the best time for energy saving and investment in the alternative energy industry. I nterestingly, the country with most serious subsidies for solar energy generation such as Spain has been caught in the deep economic crisis . In the crisis period, there will be no money left for that. 5.Europe's heel of Achilles Gas equity production is steadily declining , and this tendency cannot be stopped because of the depletion of European conventional gas fields Source : Eurogas 6.Shale gas is a miracle but it’s a local miracle With respect to success in un conventional gas , Europe will have not so much to show as the USA . The technologies used in the United States cannot be automatically transferred to Europe. More rigorous ecological standards 7.Shale gas is a miracle but it is a local miracle Optimistic forecast: shale gas in the USA will be profitable provided that its price is not less that $ 6 per thousand cubic feet which corresponds to the price of $ 210 per thousand cubic meters approximately. Source : EIA 8.Weak development of gas transportation infrastructure The EC speaks much about gas market liberalization , but does very little about it in real terms . In the USA, they build much more gas pipelines than in the EC. Most plans of construction of Underground Gas Storage facilities and LNG receiving terminals remain as they are . 9.LNG is not a panacea Though Qatar increased LNG supplies to Europe at 114% in 2009, its share equal to 15 . 9 billion cubic meters is not decisive. LNG supply growth will require serious investments in new NLG Plants in Qatar - it would be hard to achieve. Upon conditions of European economic recovery, Qatar’s LNG will cover its own declining gas production ; however, displacement of pipeline gas won't be an easy job to do. The Asian countries will provide serious rivalry fighting for LNG. 10.Competition for gas will take place anyhow The USA will likely cease import of gas . However, that will be small relief for Europe. China and India will take away considerable gas volumes including LNG . They will be major drivers of gas demand growth. The recent example: Contract between China and Australia for $ 60 billion. 11.The Turkmenian Case : defeat by China The Europeans' expectations that a weakening of Russia's positions in CAR will lead to the growth of the European influence are melting away before their eyes. It is small wonder that the Nabucco Project that was greatly relied upon has been stuck and still cannot collect the required volume of gas to ensure pumping of at least 15 billion cubic meters per year. 12.The Polish Case : How to fall into the diversification trap ? Classic example of ‘ unwise diversification ’: Poland signed a contract with RUE maintaining that that was the way to the diversification . However, they did not take into account what was the origin of the gas intended for RU Å ; say nothing about that 50% of the company is Russian-owned . Eventually, Poland signed a gas supply contract with RU Å for 2 . 5 billion cubic meters per year . As a result, when RU Å began to have difficulties with the gas in 2009 , they had to go to Gazprom for those gas volumes . While consumption of the Russian gas was declining throughout entire Europe, it increased in Poland at 14% in one year; with respect to gas volume consumption, it made Poland the fifth largest consumer of the Russian gas in Europe. 13.The Polish Case : How to fall into the diversification trap ? The second stage of ‘diversification wars’ : Poland frightens us with LNG from Qatar . However, the terminal at Port of Świnoujście in the Baltic Se a will be built by 2014 under the most optimistic scenario , and its capacity will be only 2 . 5 billion m 3 at the first stage . In addition , it is a marvel how Poland , runs away from the problem that big LNG carriers from Qatar can touch at the port via the Strait of Baltiysk . Source : Energy Charter Secretariat Qatar’s Q-Max Vessels Qatar’s Q-Flex Vessels Average Size of LNG Carrier Vessels in 2007 Average Size of LNG Carrier Vessels (Excluding Qatar Vessels) in 2007 14.The Polish Case : How to fall into the diversification trap ? 15.The gas market has been changing very fast -11 . 68% 19 . 72% -38 . 93% Total 15 . 92% -8,50% 110% 6. Great Britain 14 . 02% 14,88% 19 . 30% 5. Poland -3 . 30% 18,70% -40,30% 4. France -14 . 70% -0 . 66% -51 . 47% 3. Italy -16 . 24% -13 . 37% -31 . 53% 2. Turkey -12,65% 64 . 25% -50 . 49% 1. Germany 2009 Quarter IV , 2009 Quarter I 2009 Source: Gazprom 16.There is nothing more difficult than forecasting the evolution of gas market Market development forecasts are rewritten in the mode of Wikipedia There has never been as many experts’ speculations relating to the future gas market as in 2008-09 Source: ExxonMobil 17.Possibility of strategic mistake The EC thinks that the year of 2009 became the beginning of a long-term trend. However, referring to the perspective of 2025-2030 , the situation may turn out to be not so favorable . Europe is in a hurry to reject Russian gas and considers it expensive and politically dangerous. However, it is far from clear that it will be able to find a long-term substitution for it . It must be borne in mind that the gas market situation is changing too fast.

Special report:

Nord Stream 2 and Ukraine: Costs Should Decide

There has been much discussion about how Russia – Europe’s biggest gas supplier – can continue to supply gas to Europe over the coming decades in the most secure and cost efficient way. Gazprom and its European partners have decided that building two additional pipelines through the Baltic Sea (Nord Stream 2) is the best commercial solution to secure future gas supplies for the EU, where gas production continues to decline and demand is expected to grow.

Shale Revolution: Myths and Realities

The boom in shale gas production in the US and its wide-ranging influence on markets rocked the gas world. Liquefied gas deliveries were redirected, altering the already fragile balance of demand and supply in traditional markets for pipeline gas in Europe.

Liquefied Natural Gas Outlook: Expectations and Reality

World market has shown interest to liquefied gas. Russia has so far been aside of it. However, producers have announced several large LNG projects. The new study will help investigate this delicate subject and understand what is in store for LNG production and export in the nearest years.

Analytical series “The Fuel and Energy Complex of Russia”:

Oil and Gas Sector Regulation and Interim Results in 2024. Outlook for 2025

A new government was formed in Russia in spring 2024. Sergey Tsivilyov became Energy Minister. The first six months of the new government’s regulation of the fuel and energy sector are already past, which enables drawing the first analytical conclusions. Therefore, interim production results for 2024 have a special place in this research. We analyse the past year in two papers at once, as has become a tradition already. The gas industry is considered in a separate report. Meanwhile, we focus on oil here. The report’s special value lies in the data of our own oil export estimation model.

Northern Logistics Route: Should One Expect a Breakthrough?

The Northern Sea Route and the Arctic in general were made a state priority even before the conflict in Ukraine. The key question is: can nice talk about the NSR as a profitable and strategic route and about Russia’s return to the Arctic be converted into actual breakthroughs making it possible to carry out at least the executive’s own plans? The strategic content concerning the NSR is relatively new, but many problems are old.

Current Status of Russian Oil Exports

Getting over the 2022-2024 sanctions is the most important test for the Russian oil industry. After the US, United Kingdom, EU, and G7 introduced a ban on buying Russian oil and petroleum products (with some exceptions) and the price cap mechanism, Russia managed to find alternative sale options in countries that are now commonly called the “Global South”. However, it is important to consider exports in detail. This is what we do in the new NESF report.

Green and Climate Agenda: Reset Attempt

In spite of dramatic worsening of relations with the West, the subject of climate has not vanished from Russian economic plans. Environmental issues have even topped the list of declared problems.

Government 2024: New Configuration of Regulators

While the result of the presidential election in Russia was absolutely predictable, further moves forming new government agencies were more intriguing. Eventually, on the one hand, it would seem that Putin chose to avoid radical decisions on the civilian part of the Cabinet. Prime Minister Mishustin kept his post and almost all deputy prime ministers did. On the other, there are still meaningful changes. First of all, the Ministry of Energy got a new head. This alone deserves special attention.

Lithium: New Energy Eldorado?

The energy transition is, on the one hand, rightly perceived by Russian oil and gas companies as a threat to their business. On the other, one should also look for new opportunities in the new energy industry. One of them is the production of lithium, the most important resource for electric vehicle batteries. The industry is rapidly growing, which opens up new horizons, for conventional fuel and energy companies, among others. Lithium is already beginning to cause increased interest in Russia, which calls for close scrutiny of the topic.

West’s Latest Sanctions Decisions, Their Effect on Russian Oil and Gas Industry

The report presents an analysis of the latest sanctions decisions on the part of the US, EU, and United Kingdom as well as practical measures to implement them.

State regulation of the oil and gas sector in 2023, 2024 outlook

The year 2023 posed a serious challenge to the Russian oil and gas sector that was subjected to extremely tough sanctions that could have led to collapse in exports of crude oil and petroleum products. The oil industry and corresponding regulatory mechanisms were tested throughout the year. The state, being in dire need of financial resources, had to save the chicken that lays golden eggs. How well is it coping with this task?

All reports for: 2015 , 14 , 13 , 12 , 11 , 10 , 09 , 08 , 07

Rambler's Top100

About us | Products | Comments | Services | Books | Conferences | Our clients | Price list | Site map | Contacts

Consulting services, political risks assessment on the Fuel & Energy Industry, concern of pilitical and economic Elite within the Oil-and-Gas sector.
National Energy Security Fund © 2007